Monthly Archives: December 2013

Don’t Tread on My Metadata!

A much shorter version of my academic piece on the third-party doctrine has just been published on PJ Media. Here are the first three paragraphs. If you have time, please go read the rest, leave comments, share, etc. Any help you can give in getting the word out is greatly appreciated!

“Do you classify Edward Snowden — the former National Security Agency contractor contractor charged with espionage, and runner-up for Time‘s ‘Person of the Year’ — as a hero or a traitor? Your answer likely depends on your opinion of the NSA programs he helped publicize via his leaking of highly classified documents. In this week’s revelations, we learn that the NSA deploys agents to infiltrate online gaming communities, and that it uses the Google tracking cookies we thought were responsible only for that eerie and annoying targeted advertising. We also learned recently that the NSA collects ‘nearly 5 billion records a day on the whereabouts of cellphones around the world.’ Earlier this year, we learned that the NSA has been continuously collecting phone record ‘metadata’ of all Verizon customers for the last seven years. The NSA also accessed email and other forms of Internet communication — including Skype voice and video communications — via a secret program called Prism. Director of National Intelligence James Clapper described these programs as ‘acquiring’ information only about foreigners, and yet ’49-plus percent of the communications [intercepted and stored under the Prism program] might be purely among Americans….’

“Whatever you think of Snowden, his actions have drawn significantly more attention to the NSA’s intrusive programs. Now the question is: will anything be done about them?

“Proponents of the programs have noted that, although data collection is performed without probable cause or particularized suspicion, only transactional metadata, not the content of communications, is collected. Moreover, their proponents continue, these programs make it easier for the government to identify and track suspected terrorists, and therefore strike the right “balance” between privacy and security. In addition, some argue, the programs are perfectly legal: according to the ‘third-party doctrine,’ there is no ‘reasonable expectation of privacy’ in metadata we share with our phone companies, Internet service providers, etc., and the collection of metadata is authorized by the Patriot Act or the FISA Amendments Act.

“The applicability or purported constitutionality of these statutes is, I think, beside the point. The third-party doctrine itself is flawed and should be eliminated.

“In this article, I’ll first discuss the third-party doctrine, including its history and the types of cases to which is has been applied. Then I will propose a better way of dealing with cases typically thought to fall under this doctrine. Finally, I will use the common law of contract to answer the charge that eliminating the third-party doctrine will prevent government from using secret agents in law enforcement.”

Read the rest here.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

The Corrupt Persecution of Apple & More, Today at 12 p.m. PT (3 p.m. ET)

Today we’ll discuss the persecution of Apple by its court-appointed antitrust “monitor” and a lot more! Scroll down to the “Program Notes” to see links to all the stories, etc., we plan to discuss.

We also invite you to join in on the discussion live, either by phone or in the chatroom!

The show can be accessed here.

To access the show’s page at BlogTalk Radio, which will allow you to check out a past episode or to subscribe via iTunes and other services, use this link.

To access the iTunes store page for “Don’t Let It Go…Unheard,” where you can find past episodes, subscribe, and leave ratings and reviews (pretty please!), use this link.

Finally, if you would like to support the podcast financially, please donate using your Pay Pal account or Credit Card here.

Program Notes

New Blog: News Sandwich!

My Appearance on Objectively Speaking

Privacy in the Digital Age

The Lawfare Project

Nelson Mandela Dies at 95

U.S. Employers Add 203,000 Jobs; Unemployment Rate Falls to Five-Year Low

VodkaPundit: One of These Things Is Not Like The Other

41% Of Net New Jobs Were In Government

WSJ Opinion: Apple’s Star Chamber

A Controversial News Sandwich for December 3

“Antitrust Laws” from the Ayn Rand Lexicon

Obamacare: The Reboot

Pigs Fly: A Good News Story at the Top of Drudge

Washington Has Enrolled Almost Nine Times as Many People in Medicaid as in Private Plans

Should you Eat Lots of Nuts?

Fast-Food Strikes Return Amid Push for Wage Hikes

Fast-food workers strike for higher wages across the U.S. Thursday

11-Year-Old Girl Who Was Told To Beg Instead Of Selling Mistletoe Tells It Like It Is

Millennials Abandon Obama and Obamacare HT: Bosch Fawstin

IRS Floats Rule Changes to Tip 2014 Elections

Ted Cruz: Obama disregards the law like in ‘dictatorial societies’


Filed under Don't Let It Go...Unheard